Decision making

This discussion is closed: you can't post new comments.

When I was young, my dad taught me a way of making tough decisions. You get a sheet of paper, make one column for each of the possibilities, and list pros and cons. The one that ends up with the most (important) pros and least (important) cons is the one that you should choose. My dad is a TJ-type.

My mum also taught me a way of making tough decisions. Her way was to toss a coin. But the point was not to just toss the coin, but to see how you feel when it landed. If you’re pleased, go with it. If you’re disappointed, ignore it and go with the other choice. My mum is a FJ-type.

Now I’m an INFP, which means that the latter method appeals to me a lot more than the former. I made that table of laptops in my last post, but all it did for me was expose how many factors there are: there’s no obvious winner.

So I’ve been picturing tossing a six-sided coin (yes, I know, it’s called a die), and this is how it goes:

  • Toshiba Portege R500: I feel disappointed. My present laptop seemed pretty sturdy, and it’s broken under my (moderately heavy) usage, so I hate to think how the Toshiba would fare. I don’t want my new laptop to fall apart.
  • Dell M1330: I feel downcast. They’ve got an amazing spec, looks aren’t bad, but they’re big and weighty when I want small and light.
  • Lenovo X300: I feel appalled. Thank you to everyone who pointed this option out to me, but despite the specs I just cannot get over the design. It’s too black-boxy, business like, the very opposite of fun. It doesn’t fit with my vision of me.
  • Sony Vaio TZ32: I feel resigned. It’d be good enough, but it’s so samey. Everyone in my family has a Vaio.
  • Apple Macbook Air: I feel delighted, thrilled, excited, and a little bit naughty. It’s not the sensible option, but it’s the one my heart wants.

So there you have it, decision made. And yes, I know:

  • It doesn’t have a DVD drive; but I’ve used the DVD drive in this laptop what? three times? My previous laptop didn’t have a CD/DVD drive and it was perfectly usable day-to-day. When I needed to access a DVD, I popped it into a shared DVD drive on the desktop computer and shared it. I can do the same with the Macbook Air using Remote Disk.
  • It hasn’t got a built-in WWAN adapter; but I don’t want to fork out for always-on internet. I’m prepared to hop from hotspot to hotspot (that’s what I do at the moment anyway).
  • It hasn’t got a built-in Ethernet adapter; as above. I do remember the last time I used the Ethernet adapter on this laptop, but it was a while ago.
  • The battery’s not removable except by shipping to base; but I don’t think I’ve ever had a backup battery for any of my laptops. When they’re out of power, they’re out of power and I have to do something else with my time, until I get to charge them again. Yes, this has been frustrating on a few rare occasions, but never enough to get me to invest in another battery.
  • It’s only got 2GB memory; but I’m not even using my 1GB at the moment, even with Firefox, Oxygen, Thunderbird and Acrobat Reader open. I don’t think it’ll prove a practical limit.
  • It’s only got a 64GB hard disk; but that’s the same as the other laptops that I’ve been considering. Most of my data is held remotely on my slug and it’s good discipline to keep it there. I’m quite happy using USB drives to supplement my on-the-move storage (you can get a 16GB one for less than £50 nowadays!).

In short, all its disadvantages are things that I either don’t care about or am quite prepared to live with.

But before I order it, I want to know if any of you Mac users out there have any recommendations for must-have accessories? I was planning on getting iWork since it’s only £55 and I fancy seeing how Numbers works, and on getting the extended warranty. And a case or bag. Anything else?

Comments

Re: Decision making

I think I have to agree with the way your dad goes about the decision making process….leaving it to chance…just can’t do it.

Re: Decision making

Apple Macbook Air is pretty much sexy. Every element is super sharp, the hidden ports are a thing of beauty, and the backlit keyboard is certainly a nice touch. It’s almost silly how light it is, and multitouch is smooth as butter. With the dimensions and curves Apple is playing with, we can almost forgive the lack of removable battery — almost.

Re: Decision making

Hi Jeni,

I’ve just ordered the xps 1330, with a T9300 processor, 4gb ram and the white-led screen, all for £1100. My decision was also bewteen the MBA and the 1330, and it was really tempting to get the mac, but things like the Java 1.6 delay swung it for me.

Found this through http://planet.xsltransformations.com/ by the way…

Re: Decision making

Hiya Jenny,

I too went against the advice of your Dad a couple of months ago, and got an Mac. I haven’t looked back! =)

  • TextMate is brilliant, and the main reason I got a mac.
  • iWork is great too, although I was a little under-whelmed by Numbers - there is no facility to add a regression line being my principle niggle. Pages is great though, and Keynote provides hours of entertainment! =P
  • Macports comes in handy too.
  • Adium is a great iChat replacement, that works with googletalk, msn, aol etc. No video/audio though.
  • I’m personally not too hopeful of getting Time Machine running on other Network drives, especially now that Apple has released their Time Capsule. It is technically possible, but I’m a little wary of it, as it was seemingly disabled for some reason before Leopard shipped. In the terminal:

    defaults write com.apple.systempreferences TMShowUnsupportedNetworkVolumes 1
  • Might not be of interest, but Handbrake is a great tool for video conversion. IIRC, there is also some software, Mac The Ripper, that juts rips the films to HD. VLC Media Player is worth having too, to supplement QuickTime Player.

Re: Decision making

Jeni,

Go with iWork. It is very nicely put together and will handle most pesky Office documents that people put together.

Re: Decision making

That’s the one I’d choose out of those 4 - I wouldn’t swap my iBook for anything except another Apple, even though it’s slow (1.4GHz G4 PowerPC) and a tad short of memory.

Anyway, recommendations:

Software: Quicksilver (freeware) - at first sight, it’s ‘only’ an application launcher…but it’s so much more. TextMate ($35?) - excellent text editor Fink and/or MacPorts/DarwinPorts (whatever it’s called now) for your Unix apps.

Hardware: I’d get the USB DVD drive, but that’s because I rip a fair number of CDs to my iPod :-) I can’t think of any other hardware, apart from something to backup to with Time Machine?

Re: Decision making

Thanks for the recommendations. I’m hoping that I’ll be able to configure things so that I can backup to the slug with Time Machine…

Myers-Briggs

I’m an INTP who has spent most of his working life surrounded by INTJs. They so do not get it.

Re: Myers-Briggs

To be fair, my dad’s been trying ever so hard to cast off his J-ness and “be more P”. He sometimes even succeeds.

Re: Myers-Briggs

I once called it “increasing my P-ness”, and it took me a while to see why people laughed.

Re: Decision making

I had the same experience. The Macbook Air did not seem the most sensible choice, but I simply could not see me buying any other laptop. I have not regretted this for a single moment. It’s a wonderful laptop!

I have not yet found a bag or case that seems to suite an Air. Apple should make one!

Re: Decision making

Personally, I really like the Mighty Mouse.